Having absolutely loved Ms. Setterfield's previous work, THE THIRTEENTH TALE, I looked forward with great anticipation BELLMAN & BLACK. Unfortunately, I was sorely disappointed. I found it to be a tortuous read - written almost completely in narrative - never allowing one to truly connect with the characters. In addition, the book is littered with tedious detail about the fabric business, leaving this reader cold and bored. Sorry, but I cannot recommend it.

I fell in love with The Thirteenth Tale and waited ages to read this. What a disappointment! Is this even the same author? I stood until the end because I thought maybe there it will redeem itself, but NO! This book was dull and weird. Why so many details about the mill, the clothes, the businesses? The only thing I enjoyed was Mrs. Setterfield’s beautiful prose. At least that is still there. Not worth your money.